previous post next post  

ANZAC Day 2010

Today is ANZAC Day, the Australia-New Zealand equivalent to Memorial Day.



New Zealand Website on ANZAC Day.



The Australian Equivalent.

The Gallipoli Campaign was the brainchild of Winston Churchill, an attempt to force the Dardanelles and reach the Black Sea, freeing up the Russian Black Sea Fleet and opening up new routes of supply and a new thrust at the Austrians and Germans via the Balkans. Churchill really had the hots for the idea that Italy and the Balkans represented the "soft underbelly" of Europe. He was to be all for going in that way during WWII, as well.

Gallipoli, along with the treatment and use of Commonwealth troops in France, marked the high tide of Britain's command and control of Commonwealth Forces. The propensity of British Generals to use non-UK troops for the really bloody work, while at the same time treating them as second-class citizens, caused the command relationships to be much different in WWII. Especially since, pound for pound, the Commonwealth soldiers were in main, better quality troops than those from the UK (exceptions on both sides abounding, of course).

Like it or no, the colonials were, if nothing else, generally healthier than their UK counterparts. Regardless, all the soldier's quality was oft-times squandered by execrable generalship. In case there is any doubt how Australians felt about it, this picture is of the Sydney Memorial.

 

For the Turks? This was a moment of great pride for them, marking as it did the end of a long slide to obscurity and mediocrity, and cemented Ataturk's reforms and the establishment of a secular state - and gave the Army the imprimatur of the guardian of the state's secular nature - though that hasn't always gone well...  as today's struggle with a rising Islamism in Turkey indicates.


The Arsenal at Argghhh! has several items with an ANZAC connection. Our WWI-era Vickers machine gun is an ex-Turkish gun - and by the serial number is *not* one of the ones provided to Turkey in 1940 (to keep them neutral) but is in all probability a captured gun, reworked (the Turks were always tinkering with their weapons, trying to stretch their service life. Hi-res, click here, here, here, and here. Second, we have a M1893 Turkish Mauser, which is quite possibly (by age and ship date to Turkey) but unverifiably a Gallipoli vet. This rifle sports a Sanderson-made M1907 bayonet, captured by the Turks and reworked to fit the Mauser. We also have a 2nd Military District bayonet (Australian) that has been through the same treatment. Since invading at Gallipoli was a Brit idea, it's the Brit bayonet that hangs on the Turk rifle.


Hi-res, click here.

Last, but not least, are the dogtags. Body recovery being tough in the conditions under which the campaign at Gallipoli was fought, when Aussie troops went 'over the top' many would leave a bayonet or stick stuck in the sandbags or walls of the trench, with their dogtags hanging from 'em. If, after the battle, they were still there...

Aussie dogtags hanging from a bayonet stuck in the trench wall - if they were still there after going 'over the top'...


For the Commonwealth soldier, the equivalent of "Taps" is "Last Post".

Now is the time at Castle Argghhh! when we dance: In Memoriam

12 Comments

Great post - and the dogtags look very familiar to me (I have both the leather & silver metal ones for an adopted great uncle).  You might find the photos on my latest blog interesting.
http://marionsmeepings.blogspot.com/2010/04/anzac-memories.html

Pax
[Downunder]
 
Great post - and the dogtags look very familiar to me (I have both the leather & silver metal ones for an adopted great uncle). You might find the photos on my latest blog interesting.
http://marionsmeepings.blogspot.com/2010/04/anzac-memories.html

Pax
[Downunder]
Apologies if this posts twice - the server seems to have eaten my first attempt!
 
The Ode:-
They shall grow not old, as we that are left grow old;
Age shall not weary them, nor the years condemn.
At the going down of the sun and in the morning
We will remember them.

Amen - Seza of Melbourne, Australia
 
Anzac Cove Turkish Memorial: "Those heroes that shed their blood and lost their lives... you are now lying in the soil of a friendly country. Therefore rest in peace. There is no difference between the Johnnies and the Mehmets where they lie side by side here in this country of ours... You the mothers who sent their sons from far away countries, wipe away your tears. Your sons are now lying in our bosom and are in peace. Having lost their lives on this land they have become our sons as well."
 
Ronin - good stuff.  Now to see if I can remember to incorporate it next year.
 
Churchill's idea was quite good and General's who weren't slaves to timetables would have won a brilliant victory.  Initiative in the Briitish Amy died on the Western Front and carried over to  the Gallipoli Campaign.  If General Sir John Monash had been in command the Turks might have been driven out of Constantinople.  Might have beens -- Oh to dream.
 
The Dardanelles might have been a good idea. 

Pushing up through the various mountain lines of Italy and the Balkans, less so.

You are such an anglophile for an Irisher.
 
Wonder how Dragoon would've turned out being landed in the Balkans instead of the French Riviera. Vichy France wasn't that much of a threat at that point in time and the Warsaw Pact might've looked a bit different with the allies possibly on their way to Hungary by way of Rumania and such.
 
Well, there might have been some political issues with that.  I'm not sure that fighting our way up Greece against the Germans would have been a good idea.  Dragoon was intended to clear German forces from threatening the flank of the advance to Germany as well as providing a dagger at the flank of the Germans in Italy - but mostly was intended to secure the flank of Normandy and then provide forces for the push into Germany. 

I've not looked at the Balkan area from the perspective of invading with modern mech forces.  I.e., could we capture intact ports of sufficient capacity to supply a significant force.  We didn't have that kind of luck with France, having to supply the AEF via the beaches.
 
It might have worked, had not a Turkish Infantry officer, one Mustapha Kemal, happened to be present.  It was all balancing on the cusp, and he seized the initiative. A genius, he was.
 
 The Australian and New Zealand embassies put on a great series of events here in DC for ANZAC Day with great turnout from senior US leadership.  As soon as I get photos or video, I'll post them on at www.rsl-dc.org.blogspot.com/.
 
Ronin, that makes my eyes wet, a bit.