previous post next post  

Heh. Compare and contrast.

Michael Vick is out of jail and signed with the Eagles for 1.6 million or so after serving 19 months just down the street on his dogfighting conviction.

Donte' Stallworth finds himself unable to play football this year because he killed a man, and the league suspended him without pay.  Stallworth will also spend... 30 days in jail

Now, I realize that killing a man because you're an a$$hole out driving drunk has a very different criminal intent component vice running a dog fighting ring for years, and the crimes are apples and oranges...

But 30 days for killing someone seems a bit... light.  I love dogs as much as any PETA member, but this still just strikes me as... dissonant.  Poor Mr. Reyes seems somewhat overlooked here, however much his family may have received in compensation from Stallworth.  Of course, Mr. Reyes has some culpability for his actions in running across the road, and one has to consider the possibility that Stallworth would have hit Reyes even if Stallworth had been stone cold sober.

Remind me if I feel like driving drunk and want to take the risk of killing somebody while doing it, to do it down there in Florida (and it probably doesn't hurt to be rich and a famous football player) and not here in Kansas.  We seem to take it more seriously up here.

INVOLUNTARY MANSLAUGHTER
The Kansas Legislature passed stiffer penalties effective July 1, 1996, for those convicted of involuntary manslaughter while driving under the influence. If sentenced under this law, you will likely receive imprisonment, ranging from 38 to 172 months. A new law passed in 2001 amends the criminal history classification law dealing with the crime of involuntary manslaughter while driving under the influence of alcohol or drugs to provide that a prior DUI violation of another state's law of a city ordinance or county resolution shall count for criminal history purposes as a person felony.


Except... when you check Florida's law on the subject... they seem to take it just as seriously as Kansas does...

Manslaughter and Vehicular Homicide-s. 316.193 (3), F.S.

DUI/Manslaughter: Second Degree Felony (not more than $10,000 fine and/or 15 years imprisonment).


Heh.  Clearly, being able to afford a good lawyer and make your team competitive counts for a lot in extenuation and mitigation.

12 Comments

The girlfriend damn near exploded when she found out that the dirtbag signed with the Eagles. She is an Eagles fanatic and I headed for my bunker with 18' overhead cover when the sports came on last night's news.

My feelings are that if he learned his lesson, Mr Vick deserves a second chance. He screws up again, we introduce him to a Great Dane with an overactive libido.
 
I agree with you, Jon.
He seems to have genuinely learned the err of his ways.  I'm willing to give him a second chance... but I'm surprised that the Eagles signed him.  It's not like they need another starting QB.

The Bengals on the other hand... !!!

And you're absolutely right, John.
30 days for manslaughter!!??? WTF is that about?  You can darn well bet that if a normal person did that, they wouldn't get 30 days.
 
I'm sorry, but I'm not so ready to forgive Michael Vick.  It doesn't take a rocket scientist/brain surgeon type to know that dog fighting is morally reprehensible.  IMO, the only reason he's sorry is because he got caught.  With the reputation the Eagles have (what other NFL franchise has a judge conducting court proceedings on-site of their stadium DURING games??), I'm not really surprised that would be the franchise to step up and hire a felon.

And, as for the other?  30 days?  Drunk-driving manslaughter? Seriously?  What IS this world coming to?
 
Ahhh...Miss Ladybug...most if not all stadium have a judge assigned on game days. A friend of mine was head of security at Giant Stadium, and they have a judge, jail, court reporter, the works. You can be fined, served and sent on your way out of the stadium in minutes...if you're not too drunk.

One day I'll tell you the story about what happened to someone who actually had a Monopoly Get Out of Jail Free card in his wallet and gorked out on drugs at a concert.
 
He'd *have* to have been gorked out to pull that stunt. Everybody *knows* you're supposed to use the "Buy Tickets To Policemen's Ball" card...
 
I was unaware of that.  Back when I traveled for business, I found myself in the Philadelphia area during a football season.  They were reporting about the court at the stadium as if it was something unique (that Eagles fans had a reputation for extremely bad behavior), so I assumed it was, as I'd never heard of such a thing before...

Regardless, it's not like Vick didn't know it was wrong when he started that little enterprise...
 
Make no doubt about it- Vick did a stupid thing.  And if he does anything this stupid again, I'm more than ready to throw his bee-hind in jail for a VERY long time.  I am not giving him a free pass.  But he served his time, paid his fines, admitted wrong-doing, and is trying to get on with his life.  I see no problem with that.  It's no different than a normal person who gets caught abusing animals, goes to jail, pays his fines, sees the err of his ways, and upon release from jail, finds a job and earns a living.  Just because Vick's way of earning a living puts him in the spotlight doesn't mean he's any less deserving of the same second chance a normal person would get.

He's no role-model, and my kids know why.  But that doesn't make him a bad ball player- it just makes him someone I don't want them looking up to as some sort of sports hero.
 
The man is a sociopath by established behaviour.  You don't heal such people.  His thuggishness will break through the choreographed appearances too soon.  I can't believe groups of animal lovers would want Vick to be allowed to ever own a pet or to touch anyone else's.  Vick's "Redemption Tour" through high schools and pet venues is like taking the rapist released from prison and trotting them around the women's rape-survival groups and runaway girl's shelters.  I'm from Atlanta and Vick is dead to me.
 
 I've never been an Eagles fan.  Grew up in a Cowboy household, and still haven't forgiven Jerry Jones for how he treated Tom Landry.  For good or ill, sports stars are made to be role models, whether they deserve that exalted position or not.  Too many parents don't take the time you apparently do to talk to their kids about why certain people should not be looked up to.  I have to agree with twolaneflash's assessment: taking Vick around to these places on a "redemption tour" i grossly inappropriate....
 
I will do you one better:  Flagrant violation of the FMCSR; perjury before a grand jury and NO jail time at all.
 
Sure, Vick deserves a second chance - driving a delivery truck, working in a factory, maybe selling real estate.  Not making over a million dollars a year playing football.  Especially not for my the Eagles.
 
What you said about keeping 30 days jail for killing is lite for him. I think he should be prison for 2 to 3 years and get fined.