11 Comments
Blogads Milhive
Blogads Gunhive

Advertise on Castle Argghhh!
Blog advertising is good for you (and us)!
Project Valour - IT
Providing voice-activated laptops, Physical Therapy Wii's, and GPS devices to wounded soldiers - 2,700 and counting! Click the graphic above for more information.
Castle Comments
- Casey: Ummm, Ry? You there, buddy? (tap, tap, tap) Is this microphone on? (tap, tap) testing; ...
- Casey: Um, ry? Just checked me some Wiki combat radii, and I got: -F-35A CTOL 590 nm - ...
- ry: Hey, if you check the trend, and what both our JPN and ROK buddies want, we'll be out ...
- BillT: Flying F-22s from *Guam*? Let's say the PRC gets feisty in the Formosa Straits. The F-22s ...
- ry: Heh. COnsidering that E. Asia's my bag, well, I figure I'll throw down(and get ...
PTSD: Facts and Information
Every deployed military service member and veteran has one final, over arching mission: to come home as physically and mentally fit as possible. To find out more, please read this information.
Links Every Vet Should Have!
Every military service member, veteran, and their families or caregivers should have this list of links to VA Benefits, applying for them, appealing decisions, and in general how to get assistance. Click this link for more information. Don't be shy. It's not a handout - you earned it with your blood, sweat, and tears.
Wahabism Delenda Est!
If cease fires in the name of peace actually produced peace the Middle East would be the most peaceful place on earth by now... Read More
Mebbe it's just Clobbering Time..Just sayin'. "The Iraqis don't want Saddam back - they want the stability. But they want the stability without being fed into industrial chippers.". -The Armorer, on Hugh Hewitt, 27 December 2006. Read Less
Legal Notice To Spammers
Unsolicited advertising. If you place, or cause an agent to place, any unsolicited ads via any means, not limited to so-called 'comment spam' or 'trackback spam' you are assumed to agree to pay at the rate of $500USD per unsolicited URL. Contact the site owner for remittance instructions. Attempts will be made to collect this tariff, and a failure to make payment will result in formal actions against the advertising site.
Welcome to the Castle Argghhh!!!
This site is in no way affiliated with the Department of Defense, Department of the Army, the Department of the Air Force, or the National Guard Bureau and nothing said herein should be considered to have any official sanction by those (or any other) agencies Read More
We're just retired warriors and fellow-travelers and all opinions
expressed herein are mine or Dusty's or Bill's, or Kat's, or Fuzzybear's;(and
the odd guest-poster like Cassandra and the Wicca Pundit) unless quoted from
other sources. This site does *not* have the Rumsfeld Gates Seal of Approval
and we doubt he knows (or cares) it exists! [Um, well, it
turns out he *does* and so does Army Secretary Geren, too.]Though we
*have* seen the Official Army Blog Training Brief, and we know that the *Counter-Intel*
people know it exists... [Waving vigorously] "Hi fellas! How are ya?"
However, we *do* know the blog is read at the White House. Because we got invited there. Kewl, huh?
Read Less
Feeds from the Castle
All rights reserved. © other material retained by owners and used by permission or excerpted under "Fair Use"


Ummmmmm -- too bad they can't *both* do *both*...like helicopters can...
[scrambling for the bunker]
Right now, I'm just using bandwidth while I can...
It takes *forever* for helicopters to self-deploy.
Oh, heck, let's get Dusty started on that topic.
I won't have to post for a week.
8^)
where you can station them and how you get them to the fight matters, too. An AF of F-35s doesn't stand a chance of getting to the fight(legs are too short). The F-35C(vstol) hasn't even been done acceptance trials yet. So Nava; aviation of the suckers is 2-20 years into the future. Figuring that we'll have to fly either from JPN(and I wouldn't bet on getting to use that training strip they've got sitting right on the CADIZ line in the Ryuku chain), or Guam, I'm for the F-22 given a crisis in the near to mid-term. Cost and all. She's the only bird that can do what's needed. Period. Gotta deal with the necessity instead of just numbers, y'all.
IF we had the F-35C in hand, and a large number of L ships and escorts, well, I'd say fine. Take the F-22 off the table. THe Navy and Marines could kick in the door, set up rough and ready fields for the golfers, er, excuse please, the AF to work off of and extend further inland. But, we don't have the triad to make that viable. So, the AF gets the 22, and can come play on day one with good odds of survivability and making a major difference.
BUt that's me. ;)
Let's say the PRC gets feisty in the Formosa Straits. The F-22s could make Taiwan unrefueled, using drop tanks, but then they'd have to tank before engaging in combat, then refuel over Taiwan, then at least twice more during the return trip to Anderson.
Then they'd have to refuel, rearm, and go back and do it again. And again.
Without losing any to combat action or maintenance glitches.
Nevah hoppen.
That's kinda why that Ryuku island right on the CADIZ line is kinda important, Unk. Stagging P-3/P-X and other fighters out of there would make things soooooooo much easier. But, again, try convincing the Diet to go for it while the PLA's doctrine amounts to 'if you attack from there we can attack you there'---which means alla Nihon is on the table according to the Chinee. Hence, the Diet'll neve go for it.
Hey, remember, Unk, I was the guy chastizing Kat about sortie time/rate back the last time this came up. It sucks. WHich is why I'm saying without the -35C it's the only bird the AF has that can get to the fight. THe -35 faces an even worse problem of refueling.
Formosa is largely a Navy problem, but any problem in the Western Pac requiring AF will have to be served by the -22. She's the only one of the two with the range to make it across with what's available in tanker capacity(and where they're located/can be located).
But, yeah, I now about the problem of sortie. That's why the AF shows up to keep the PLAAF off the Super Hornets in most scenarios I've seen that win. Beat back all that Russian crap, let the Hornets go after the transports. That's what she, the F-22, can do.
But, hey, if'n 'ya wanna talk Barry into forking out the kroner for a mother-load of amphibs capable of carrying a dozen F-35 each and get rid of the super-carriers, for major savings(in some areas), I'd be down with that too. You know you got the pull, Unk. You're just that nifty. ;)
-F-35B STOVL 450 nm
-F-35C CV 600 nm
-F/A-18A/C 290 nm
-F/A-18 Super Hornet 390 nm
-F-16C (Block 30) 295 nm
-F-22 410 nm
Now. What was that about short legs, again?
I do like your idea F-35-capable amphib, though. Do we have any old Midway- or Essex-class carriers in mothballs to try that out? :) More seriously, aren't the modern amphibious assault ships nearly the same dimensions as the Essex?
You there, buddy?
(tap, tap, tap) Is this microphone on?
(tap, tap) testing; one two three...
er, what was that again about long legs?