previous post next post  

Fear the Reaper

According to the Strateg Page, the first squadron of manned F-16's have been fully replaced by unmanned Reapers.

August 11, 2008: The U.S. Air Force is, for the first time, converting a fighter wing from manned (F-16) combat aircraft, to unmanned ones (the MQ-9 Reaper.) The conversion, for the 174th Fighter Wing, has been in the works for three years, and the last combat sorties in manned aircraft were flown last week, by members of the 174th serving in Iraq.

According to Strategy Page, the Reaper can stay in the air for up to 14 hours over target, carries the same payloads and costs a third of the price of an F-16.  And, don't forget the life of a pilot that is safely ensconsed back in Las Vegas or someplace slightly closer. 

There are a few issues to keep in mind when contemplating an all out electronic army of robots controlled by satellite radio relay.  Primarily, your satellite could go down and so could your command and control.  Neither would you want, nor would robots be able to, make decisions on the ground or in the air like a human soldier/pilot.  Which means, if your comms go dark, so does your war.

Which, in the long run, means that, whatever our technological advancements, we should neither take human compassion out nor human reasoning. 

Heh.  Why do I have the opening scenes from the original Terminator running through my mind?

Ace of Spades

5 Comments

I was talking to Keith about the UAV's a couple of weeks ago.  He said that he heard the pilots of these vehicles were getting combat air awards.  Doesn't seem right to me, since, as you noted, the pilot is tucked safely away at an airbase in Nevada.
Has anyone else heard this? 
 
I have to look this up, but I think I did hear that was possible.  I think they are at least getting air medals though not necessarily distinguished flying crosses.  If I recall one of the stories, a UAV pilot had swooped in with his predator or whatever and saved the ground troops so his commander put him in for a medal. 

Now we will see what happens.
 
I think they are at least getting air medals though not necessarily distinguished flying crosses. Heh. Check the entry on that *very* same subject at John's other hidey-hole. http://disgruntledmajors.blogspot.com/ Scroll down a bit -- there are a couple of entries and a *lot* of comments. I can't access the site from here because our server's being exceptionally peckish. But my thoughts on that matter are public record.
 
But...which would be more useful right now over South Ossetia:  F-16s, or Reapers?

You can't fly those drones in the presence of enemy fighters, at least not if you want them to stay airborne for very long.
 
Damn.... I had a feeling that rumor was true.  WTF is that all about!??!?!!!????  If you save lives on the ground thousands of miles away, yeah, you should be recognized.  But award medals for VALOR during combat to, as the author of that post put it, "someone who only risks impacting the earth if they trip out of the control van" diminishes medals awarded for true valor under fire.
What a boondoggle.