previous post next post  

The Code of Conduct.

Regarding the Brits captured by the Iranians.

On 13 April, an Air Force Captain named Lance Sijan would have turned 65. He would have, at least, had he not chosen a different path from that chosen by the Brits. The difference in the respective approaches is what underlies the discussion of the behavio(u)r of the Brit sailors and Marines.

I've been pretty quiet on the issue, actually. Initially, I wanted more information, though from what we had I was appalled at the response of British leadership, military and political. As the debacle continued, I became more appalled with the response of the Brit leadership, military and political.

As the story became clearer, I was less sympathetic to the individuals actually involved, though I'm still not quite as bloodthirsty as many have been... because I see it mostly as a failure of leadership.

Then I remembered Lance Sijan, triggered, no doubt, by Dusty's post on the subject of the Code of Conduct and the duties and responsibilities of the American warrior.

Meet Captain Lance Sijan, from the Wikipedia post about him:

...After almost a whole day of locating his position and softening up air defences in the area, the SAR forces were finally able to get one of the big Jolly Green Giant helicopters roughly over Sijan's position (during this operation over 20 aircraft were disabled, due to the anti-aircraft fire, and had to return to base. Another aircraft was also shot down, though it's pilot was rescued with ease by one of the Jolly Greens on station.) Sijan, refusing to put another person in danger, insisted that he crawl in to the jungle and have a penetrator lowered by the helicopter, instead of sending down the helicopter's Para-Jumpers to carry him. However, he couldn't reach the penetrator quick enough, and after 33 minutes the rescue team, which faced enemy fire and the growing darkness, had to return to base. Although search efforts continued the next day, they were called off when no further radio contact was made with Sijan, due to his unconscious state, and he was placed in MIA status.

With a fractured skull, mangled right hand, compound fracture of the left leg, without food and little water, and no survival kit, Sijan evaded enemy forces for 46 days (all the time "crawling" or rather scooting on his back down the rocky limestone karst on which he landed, causing even more wounds) before being captured on December 25, 1967. Although emaciated and in poor shape, he managed to overpower his guard and escape, but was recaptured within hours. He was transported to a holding compound in Vinh, North Vietnam, where he was put into the care of other American POWs. Here, in even more pain from his wounds, he suffered beatings from his captors, but never gave any information other than what the Geneva Convention allowed. After further travel to Hanoi, Sijan suffering from exhaustion, malnutrition, and disease, died in captivity on January 22, 1968.

Sijan was promoted posthumously to captain on June 13, 1968. His remains were repatriated on March 13, 1974 and positively identified on April 22, 1974. He is buried in Arlington Park Cemetery in Milwaukee, Wisconsin.

That is how I like to believe I would have behaved, though you never know until you do it.

This is how it should be done. This is a good standard against which to measure yourself.

Normally, at this point in a post like this, the Denizens dance to the tune of Taps.

Not this time. There is, I think, more appropriate music to dance to in honor of the memory of Captain Sijan. We mourn not his passing, but we celebrate a Warrior, the mettle of whom is a basis of success or failure - if their leadership is up to the task.

So, now is the time at Castle Argghhh! when we dance: In celebration of a Warrior

10 Comments

In 1985, Readers' Dige did a condensation of his biography, Into the Mouth of the Cat. Nice to see it's in reprint -- it's a worthy read..
 
I have to say, I still didn't rant on about the sailors the way I want to simply because I don't think I have to. Whatever needs to be rectified in their individual characters will be done through attrition in the ranks. These folks will not be put back on their ship I don't think. Particularly Mr. Bean since he will be ridiculed beyond belief or, at the least, cause some serious unit cohesion issues. Faye Turney very likely has the same problem. She broke in less than 24 hours and apparently over a questionable lie regarding the release of the others, being "stripped" and made to put on some other clothes. It didn't take much. Probably a good thing she got nearly 200k for her story. I think she is going to be offered an early discharge due to trauma. any takers on that bet? As for the future of captive Brits, while I won't say they won't be taken captive or that they will even fight capture off, I think we will see a different behavior from any in the future after this very public example of what not to do. Even if the MOD does not issue a memo on the subject or revise any training manuals. Finally, the person I would like to bring to our attention is a Col. Cornum (previoiusly Maj Cornum) who was shot down over Iraq in Desert Storm, suffered broken arms, bullet wound in the shoulder and smashed knees, was subsequently abused by her captors. Or even the 7 captured at the beginning of the war. Those folks had to be scared spitless, yet, when they were forced on TV, they were very careful what they said and neither denied or confirmed what the Iraqis were demanding. Surely, they had to be quite a bit more afraid of the situation then these British soldiers. Beyond that, I think that I've said already somebody was obviously very lacadaisical in the SOP for interdiction in allegedly terrorist infested waters close on to so many potential hostiles. Black mark on the record please.
 
I agree that a "failure of leadership" contributed to the behavior of the British detainees in Iran, but I'm afraid a larger societal and cultural dynamic is also at work here. We've just seen the consequences of years of "progressive" inculcation of "cultural equivalence" and "moral relativism". How can we really expect people to endure pain, hardship, suffering, sacrifice, and even death in the name of service to one's country, when they've been "educated" their whole lives to believe there's nothing instrinsically better or superior about their own countries and cultures that are worth it?
 
Because, Frank - like in my 'teamwork' post - you do it for your buddies. The rest of the issues be damned.
 
Sorry, I missed the "Teamwork" post. I agree with everything you've said there, too, John. But even that, IMHO, leads to another current social and cultural dynamic. LOL Wherein, during the same period that our youth have been inculcated with that "moral relativism" and "cultural equivalence" junk, they've had their senses of "self-esteem" and egos over-developed to the detriment of the "team" and the community. There's been so much focus on "uniqueness", "self-absorption", and materialistic "what's in it for ME?", that I don't think many people ... especially in Europe ..... place much priority on "teamwork". We've seen fine exceptions to this in the US military .... despite the "Army of One" double meaning ..... but Europe and Britain are another matter. LOL
 
All four years I was at USAFA, I lived in Vandenburg Hall, the "old" dorm. The "new" dorm on the opposite side of the Cadet Area didn't have a name until I was a senior. That year ('75-'76) we dedicated it Sijan Hall. One of the few ceremonies I remember as a Cadet.
 
Frank, in most of the US, I would have to agree with you that the "gimme, gimme, gimme, forget about you" mentality is alive and well, however, all you need to do is spend time with a platoon that has just returned from Injun country and you will see men and women that have learned that, no matter the cost, there is someone who will stand next to them. One GREAT example of this is This young man.
 
Dance... Dance... wherever you may be.... I am the Lord of the Dance said He.... I'd like to think his wounds are healed and he's dancing a mean jig in the clouds.
 
The English have come a long way from this: The Private of the Buffs.
 
Trackbacked by The Thunder Run - Web Reconnaissance for 04/17/2007 A short recon of what’s out there that might draw your attention.