previous post next post  

Juxtapositions.

Email box pinged yesterday, with this delivered:


IMMEDIATE RELEASE No. 1333-05
December 28, 2005
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
DoD Identifies Army Casualties

The Department of Defense announced today the death of two soldiers, who were supporting Operation Iraqi Freedom.

They died in Baghdad, Iraq on Dec. 26, when their Apache helicopter collided with another military aircraft in mid-air and then crashed. Both soldiers were assigned to the 1st Battalion, 4th Aviation Regiment, Aviation Brigade, 4th Infantry Division, Fort Hood, Texas.

Killed were:

Chief Warrant Officer Richard M. Salter, 44, of Cypress, Texas.
Chief Warrant Officer Isaias E. Santos, 28, of Ancon, Panama.

The incident is under investigation.

Even though Bill is usually up on things like this from his own sources, I send these along to him, as the Aviation community is small, and a tight-knit group.

Bill responded with this:

Desertion lands pilot in jail for 10 months. Spartanburg soldier abandoned his Guard unit before Iraq deployment

By CHUCK CRUMBO, Staff Writer

An S.C. National Guard helicopter pilot has been sentenced to 10 months in a military prison for deserting his unit before it deployed to Iraq.

Chief Warrant Officer Alex Pitts of Spartanburg pleaded guilty to two separate charges of desertion and one charge of being away without leave (AWOL) under the Uniform Code of Military Justice.

Pitts also pleaded guilty to "missing movement" — a military charge for not reporting when his unit left McEntire Joint National Guard Base for Fort Bragg, N.C., and eventual deployment to Iraq.

Pitts was a member of Company D, 1st Battalion, 151st Aviation Regiment. Two of the unit's pilots were killed Dec. 9, 2004, in a crash with another helicopter near Mosul, Iraq.

According to Army documents, Pitts reported for duty Aug. 10, 2004, and then "attempted to shirk combat duty by quitting (the) unit."

The Apache unit then left Aug. 13, 2004, for Fort Bragg with Pitts missing, the documents said.

Pitts resurfaced in December 2004 at Fort Hood, Texas. When Army officials learned Pitts was an aviator, he was ordered to go to Fort Bragg.

But Pitts never reached Fort Bragg. He later was apprehended at his home in Spartanburg and then sent to Fort Knox, Ky.

Pitts was to be held in the Personnel Control Facility until he could be transported to Fort Gordon for court-martial. When MPs went to Fort Knox on May 13 to pick up Pitts, who was restricted to the post, he was gone.

On May 26, authorities found him at a house he was renting in Spartanburg and took him to Fort Gordon, according to the Army report.

Prior to the call-up of his unit, Pitts spent 18 months training to be a chief warrant officer and an Apache pilot, said Guard spokesman Lt. Col. Pete Brooks.

Pitts pleaded guilty Dec. 12 to all charges at a court-martial at Fort Gordon, Ga.

Pitts also received a dishonorable discharge and was fined $100,000. If he doesn't pay the fine, Pitts will have to serve six more months in prison.

Desertion is a rare charge among National Guard members. Brooks said this is the first incident since he became spokesman for the S.C. Guard 14 years ago.

I've always thought that the sentence for wartime desertion should be "the duration of the conflict, plus 6 months, or final redeployment, whichever is later."

Just sayin'.

Bill largely agrees. What say you?

Update: Outlaw 13 provides *focus*.

As all the comments so far have been in reference to the aforementioned scumbag deserter...I'd like to put in my two cents about the late Matt Salter and his front seater Isaias Santos.

I know Matt from a previous assignment as did many of my co-workers. Matt was a great guy with a great family and his and Mr. Santos loss saddens all of us.

When you contrast their sacrifice with the cowardly actions of Mr. Pitts no amount of punishment is worthy the same he has brought on the Attack community, the Warrant Officer Corps and the United States Army. I personally would bush him to PV1 and have him ride convoy duty on RTE Irish for as long as his unit is deployed. As George C. Scott in Patton said, "You're going to the front my friend, and you may be shot and you may be even killed but I will not have this place of honor defiled by your presence." or words to that effect. (sorry didn't look up the script).

I could go on about how the system screwed up and allowed a person like Mr. Pitts through but all that would accomplish is to raise my blood pressure even more.

Mr. Santos and Mr. Salter will be waiting for us at Fiddlers Green...save us a cold one.

Thanks for the words, Outlaw. Now, at least, when people Google the Castle for Pitts... they'll get the good words about Mssrs Santos and Salter.

17 Comments

I thought deserters were shot. In this type of war isn't desertion always "in the face of the enemy"? There are no front lines and the homeland has been attacked directly. I think this sentence is far too lenient.
 
JimC - The misplaced "leniency" is the gist of what the rest of us Aviator types have been saying, but in much cruder language. And the Apache guys have been especially virulent. We also commented on the reason desertion is such a rare charge in the Guard--and it's *not* because there haven't been instances of it. When desertion occurs, the charge is usually reduced to "missing movement"--the penalties for which are worse than those for AWOL, but entirely more lenient than those which can be prescribed for desertion in time of war...
 
I would tend to agree with John, duration plus X months, versus execution, in a case like this. But, then again, if he were to leave during battle - leaving troops unprotected or (worse even) behind on the field -- death would be the sentence I would expect. Is it fair to call them both desertion and have different sentences?
 
"Desertion in the face of the enemy" is the more serious charge.
 
And it's the more serious charge for the reasons Barb mentioned. In the mil world, you may redeem yourself in our eyes after an act of cowardice which affects only you, but expect no forgiveness from us for a cowardly act which results in the death of comrades. In that instance, forgiveness is God's provenance. Sure, it's harsh. So is recovering the bodies of your friends.
 
I'm think a year in jail and dishonorable ischarge is enough. You really don't need to throw the book at an aviator who's getting a dishonorable the military is already kicking the aviator out punishing for punishment sake's is not really the American way.This veteran understands some of our service members wind up with PTSD or just cold feet. Better to just kick em' out
 
This veteran and son/grandson-of-two-others understands that too, Tommy. Nonetheless. If the punishment amounts to a *reward,* it's not useful. Let him serve the same time in penance his comrades are serving subject to being in harm's way. I don't see anything un-American Way in that. We're not talking draftees here. And this guy, to get into the cockpit of an Apache, is not only a many-times-over volunteer, he's an *expensive* many-times-over volunteer. And the $100,000 fine probably does *not* recoup the cost of flight training.
 
I can't say it better than John and Bill have in the last few comments. I don't think it is 'throwing the book' at the man to see that he sits in prison for the deployment term plus 6-months or a year.
 
I tend to agree with Barb and John on this one. This punishment amounts to safe cold storage state-side and early release. I think Duration +6 Months is entirely reasonable. Though, it would have sorta sucked for him if he'd pulled it in Korea. I'm not sure what 'punishment for punishment's sake' is.. As John points out we as taxpayers invested mightily in this man for training. Wasted, all of it. And now we have to burn even more resources on him. I say punish away, and publicize the hell out of it, so we don't get any more like him. Then again, i'm a fairly vicious human being, that thinks even 1 count of 1st degree murder is justification for the death penalty in all cases...
 
Yeah John I can see where you're coming from. It's just as you know there are several ways to get kicked out of the service where the servicemember doesn't go to jail. The last thing the troops need in a combat zone is a pilot who's not focused on the mission. A dishonorable discharge will ground a chopper pilot in the civilian world. Nobody would want the liabilty.
 
Better he turn tail now than when he is flying someone's wing. While this is the lesser of the two evils, 10 months in the stockade while his unit is pulling a 12 month tour seems insufficient. There's also the 18 months of training to take into account.
 
Tommy - Bad paper isn't the deterrent it once was--I only had one civilian (potential) employer even ask to see my DD-214. And a military helicopter pilot does not necessarily transition into civil aviation. Someone with lots of experience and training equates to an expensive hire in the minds of a lot of operators, who are usually operating on a tight budget. Throw in flight records detailing several thousand hours and now the chief pilot starts thinking you're after *his* job...
 
As all the comments so far have been in reference to the aforementioned scumbag deserter...I'd like to put in my two cents about the late Matt Salter and his front seater Isaias Santos. I know Matt from a previous assignment as did many of my co-workers. Matt was a great guy with a great family and his and Mr. Santos loss saddens all of us. When you contrast their sacrifice with the cowardly actions of Mr. Pitts no amount of punishment is worthy the same he has brought on the Attack community, the Warrant Officer Corps and the United States Army. I personally would bush him to PV1 and have him ride convoy duty on RTE Irish for as long as his unit is deployed. As George C. Scott in Patton said, "You're going to the front my friend, and you may be shot and you may be even killed but I will not have this place of honor defiled by your presence." or words to that effect. (sorry didn't look up the script). I could go on about how the system screwed up and allowed a person like Mr. Pitts through but all that would accomplish is to raise my blood pressure even more. Mr. Santos and Mr. Salter will be waiting for us at Fiddlers Green...save us a cold one.
 
One-Three - I didn't post the e-mail chatter, but most of it had to do with the crew and their loss. The AH-64 community's not that large and both left friends in- and outside the 1-4th.
 
I thought that a deserter was shot. I think that 10 months, plus 6 months (who is going to choose to pay $100,000 over six months away?), is not sufficient punishment. I think he should be in for the duration plus six months. But he should AT LEAST be in as long as his unit would have been away. At that shouldn't include anytime while he was waiting for trial, either. When the punishment doesn't involve potential death, which this doesn't, I think the time element should be much less lenient.
 
Sir: I am in Iraq. Have been here for two years. I knew Mr. Santos. He is as a son to me. There is more to this "incident" than we have heard so far. Mr. Santos and Mr. Salter were among the finest. Keep me posted, I will do the same. jimspiri@yahoo.com
 
My deepest condolences to CW4 Salter's and CWO Santos' family. I served with Mr. Salter on several continents defending peace. I agree with the good souls' comments ahead of me - - those two aviators are at Fiddler's Green, waitin' for us with a few cold ones. If there must be trouble, let it be in my day, that my child may have peace. -Thomas Paine I love the man that can smile in trouble, that can gather strength from distress, and grow brave by reflection. 'Tis the business of little minds to shrink, but he whose heart is firm, and whose conscience approves his conduct, will pursue his principles unto death. -Thomas Paine
 
© 2008 John Donovan
All rights reserved.