previous post next post  

The Culture of the Veil.

Perhaps SWWBO and "S" have a point... and, as Aaron observes, I'm just being too easy on 'em.

From Steven Vincent's piece in today's National Review Online:

...We were sitting outside the British military base at Basra International Airport, waiting for soldiers to open the gate. The afternoon was hot, a desert wind blowing dust and grit across the asphalt. As the boredom mounted, a trucker stood and crossed the roadway. Looming over Nour, he snapped something in Arabic, causing her expression to fall and her body to flinch as she curled her legs beneath her. As the trucker strode back to his companions, I asked Nour what he'd said. "He demanded that I sit more like a respectable Muslim woman," she replied in an embarrassed voice. Angered at the man's effrontery, I rose to confront him, only to be halted again by Nour's demurrals. "You'll only cause me trouble." Sadly, she was right. Convening a one-man Morals Police for the sole purpose of humiliating a woman, the trucker had acted in the name of the force we had no defense against: Islam.

A small incident, perhaps — yet it's hard to overstate its symbolism, or the problems its portends for Iraq's future. Something frightening lies at the heart of this nation, I've come to understand, something dark, irrational, thuggish, especially among the "ignorant men" of its lower classes. In public, it often takes the forms of a weaponized stare that glowers at an unescorted woman — or a woman accompanied by a foreigner — as if yearning to see her disgrace herself, do something scandalous or un-Islamic, in order to fuel invidious gossip and innuendo. In private, it manifests itself in the threat, and frequently the reality, of violence to restrain and subjugate females. To accommodate and placate this malevolence, Iraqi females learn to repress their own behavior and instincts, while safeguarding their most important social possession — reputation.

One wonders why the left, especially, seems to want to defend this culture, even elevate it, while at the same time casting fundamentalist christians into the ninth ring of the leftist version of hell?

It is impossible to grasp the psychic claustrophobia this attitude creates for women without actually experiencing it. One afternoon, Nour and I took a boat ride down the Shatt-al-Arab waterway. The pilot, a barely literate teenager, insisting on turning around and looking at us, as if supervising our behavior. Irritated by his glare, I suggested to Nour we ask the kid — or even pay him — to face the front of the boat. "Oh no!" she protested. "Then he'll think we are really doing something scandalous and he'll tell his friends and I'll never be able to take a boat ride again." For most of the trip, we sat under the teen-ager's gaze, trying to ignore it. As we disembarked, Nour muttered, "Now you see why I hate these ignorant men?"

She's not alone. The rage and despair women feel toward religious and social customs is palpable. Take TV newscaster Najiah Abdulsala. On camera, the attractive Basran reads the news sans scarf. "I know it's against Islam, but I don't care — it's my choice!" she told me at her office. On the streets, however, Najiah is careful to wear hijab. "Religious men verbally assault me and I've received warnings from the Islamic parties," she said angrily. "Fortunately, I am marrying and my husband is taking me to Kuwait." Another Basran is not so lucky. She told me how her four brothers dominate every aspect of her life — when she can leave home, with whom, for how long. "If I run away, they will track me down and kill me." Once, when they discovered that she planned to marry without their permission, they beat her so badly they broke her arm.

I don't get it. Obviously.

Wahabism Delenda Est.


The whole piece is here.

1 Trackbacks

TrackBack this entry at http://www.thedonovan.com/cgi-bin/mt41/mt-tb.cgi/2069

Beth, She Who Will Be Obeyed, has posted: When I was in elementary school - all girl Catholic school - Mother Earhardt was our religion teacher from 1st to 4th grade. She once said that if you think of a... Read More

4 Comments

She is fortunate to be going to Kuwait. I have in-law family there and although it is not like here, it is signifantly better. Women are subjugated in many areas of the world, it is just being spoken of in the Middle East... for now. The attentions will turn eventually elsewhere. Unfortunately. What happens to women in parts of Africa is equally awful, if not more so, in their sexual treatment, circumcision etc. I could probably go on and on for various countries, but it is pointless as I think we are all aware. Not to be a pessimist, but rather a realist, I don't see any of this changing in my lifetime. Hopefully I am wrong.
 
When I posted this, I thought to myself... "Trolling for Jack..." Caught ya! 8^)
 
"Wahhabism Delenda Est" I go along with that, Sir John. But what I find aggravating (perhaps even Argghhhravating, which is a more intense degree of aggravating) is that I believe, based on the attitudes displayed in the NRO article, that it will be necessary to look beyond Wahhabism, and deal with quite a good chunk of Islam. Those obnoxious thugs waiting to be waved through the checkpoint in Basra hadn't been exposed to Wahhabism any time during the Saddam regime, Saddam was pretty diligent about controlling the form of religious expression while he was in power. These dummies act like this without ever having been to a Saudi-built and run madrassa. And there are hundreds of millions of these types in the Muslim countries today. It is the work of generations to contain them, and we might have to confront what Bin Laden was trying to start, a holy war between Islam and Civilisation, because it looks as if any version of Islam with which we could get along would not be Islam in the form we've come to recognize it, Wahhabism or no. Not the most original thought, I realize, and of course, it is best if I am wrong. Anyway, thanks for the link and the blog.
 
That's kinda the thrust of my thoughts - and the ones that so distress Jack at Random Fate. I am not among the "kill 'em all" school - but I think it's going to be a long fight - and unlike the Catholic Church's evolution, there is no "center of gravity" for Islam, aside from the holy sites, which is not the way to go about this. There is no Papacy to reform. Any charismatic loon on a hill will do - and there are far more David Koresh/Rev. Jim Jones analogues out there in the Muslim world than there in the fundamentalist christian world.
 
© 2008 John Donovan
All rights reserved.