previous post next post  

There's a movie in here.

Say what you want about 'mercenaries' - but if you are going into this kind of work, this sounds like a company to work for. Hey, Mel Gibson - we need a movie!

Private Guards Repel Attack On U.S. Headquarters

By Dana Priest, Washington Post Staff Writer

An attack by hundreds of Iraqi militia members on the U.S. government's headquarters in Najaf on Sunday was repulsed not by the U.S. military, but by eight commandos from a private security firm, according to sources familiar with the incident.

Before U.S. reinforcements could arrive, the firm, Blackwater Security Consulting, sent in its own helicopters amid an intense firefight to resupply its commandos with ammunition and to ferry out a wounded Marine, the sources said.

Taking care of their own, and the client. No medals, no parades, no fawning public.

The role of Blackwater's commandos in Sunday's fighting in Najaf illuminates the gray zone between their formal role as bodyguards and the realities of operating in an active war zone. Thousands of armed private security contractors are operating in Iraq in a wide variety of missions and exchanging fire with Iraqis every day, according to informal after-action reports from several companies.

In Sunday's fighting, Shiite militia forces barraged the Blackwater commandos, four MPs and a Marine gunner with rocket-propelled grenades and AK-47 fire for hours before U.S. Special Forces troops arrived. A sniper on a nearby roof apparently wounded three men. U.S. troops faced heavy fighting in several Iraqi cities that day.

Which illustrates what well trained soldiers can do against people who think of themselves as 'warriors'. The warrior generally loses against soldiers. The group discipline thing, doncha know.


...With their ammunition nearly gone, a wounded and badly bleeding Marine on the rooftop, and no reinforcement by the U.S. military in the immediate offing, the company sent in helicopters to drop ammunition and pick up the Marine.

I've got to admit - this is a little puzzling. The Coalition Provisional Authority Headquarters, and it took HOURS to get a reaction force to the area? Things are leaner there than I think I understood.

Without commenting at a news conference yesterday on the role of the Blackwater guards, Kimmitt described what he saw after the fighting ended. "I know on a rooftop yesterday in An Najaf, with a small group of American soldiers and coalition soldiers . . . who had just been through about 3 1/2 hours of combat, I looked in their eyes, there was no crisis.

"They knew what they were here for," he continued. "They'd lost three wounded. We were sitting there among the bullet shells -- the bullet casings -- and, frankly, the blood of their comrades, and they were absolutely confident."

Rough men, standing ready to do violence on our behalf.

A Defense Department spokesman said that there were no military reports about the opening hours of the siege on CPA headquarters in Najaf because there were no military personnel on the scene. The Defense Department often does not have a clear handle on the daily actions of security contractors because the contractors work directly for the coalition authority, which coordinates and communicates on a limited basis through the normal military chain of command.

While I understand why things are the way they are - it seems a little more direct coordination might be in order!

Blackwater, a security and training company based in Moyock, N.C., prides itself on the high caliber of its personnel, many of whom are former U.S. Navy SEALs. It has 450 employees in Iraq, many of them providing security to CPA employees, including the U.S. administrator, L. Paul Bremer, and to VIPs visiting Iraq.

3 Trackbacks

TrackBack this entry at http://www.thedonovan.com/cgi-bin/mt41/mt-tb.cgi/1697

Another Take from INDC Journal: "Randomly Tested for Lead-Poisoning" on April 6, 2004 10:15 AM

... on those horrible mercenary war-profiteers.... Read More

First off...  any spambots reading this should immediately go here, here, here, and here.  Die spambots, die!  And now...  here are all the links submitted by members of the Watcher's Council for this week's vote. Council links:Lame Def... Read More

The Council Has Spoken! from Watcher of Weasels on April 8, 2004 9:09 PM

First off...  any spambots reading this should immediately go here, here, here, and here.  Die spambots, die!  And now...  the winning entries in the Watcher's Council vote for this week are Iraq - A Matter of Perspective by Exultate Ju... Read More

4 Comments

You better not show this thread to Kos and his League of Angry Idiots. They would more than likely egg your house or some other equally horrendous fit of massive destruction! ;-)
 
"The group discipline thing" is what most folks don't fully grasp, even when you always hear the lopsided kill ratios of American engagements. People think it's merely technology (which it is as well, with marksmanship), but in ground engagements a huge factor is how well trained our guys are to work together and just wipe people out. Lame story, but I used to play paintball with a regular club of somewhat skilled dudes ... or that's what I thought until a group of marines came to play one day, and proceeded to hand us our ass over and over and over again. The superior fire and cover tactics and communication were just overwhelming. It was amazing.
 
You just described the classic warrior/soldier fight. Absent overwhelming numbers and/or bad leadership/tactics (Little Big Horn, Isandlhwana, Khartoum, Teutoburg Forest come to mind) it's not a fair fight, really. Which is just the way I like 'em, if I'm in 'em (on the soldier side, of course!) And I've done the paintball thing before, too, the slaughter of the innocents. But the last couple of paintball fights I've watched - people (absent swaggering hero types) are learning the lesson on their own, and could probably make a good fight about it. The thing about soldiers (especially the combat experienced ones) is that they are more cautious about exposing themselves, having heard the little bees buzzing overhead. Paintball warriors *know* they can't be hurt, not in a meaningful way - which leads them to impatience, and false heroics. The type that get that kind of soldier killed early on - so that the survivors are the canny, cagey ones. Darwin is a real bastard on a battlefield. On the flip side, enough exposure to combat, and the soldier starts to get fatalistic, and with that comes carelessness. Which is why you need to pull veteran formations out for a rest now and again. Inadvertently, that's what we did with the Airborne and Armored divisions in WWII. While the regular infantry division just got ground down, the Airborne and Armored Divisions were committed to specifics fights and campaigns, and then withdrawn to rest and refit - whereas the line infantry divisions were many times just kept in the grinder, and new meat fed in. Reading the memoirs of the soldiers of the Airborne and Armored Divisions vice the poor bloody infantry in the line divisions, you can see the differences. Of course, there are exceptions to all of it - but I think as a general trend it's a supportable argument.
 
You just hit another thing that struck me from my paintball days - how easy it is to get nailed, especially with rapid-fire semi-auto or auto weapons. Ass up out of the ditch? Nailed. Arm sticking slightly out from tree? Nailed. And bullets go through foliage a lot better than paintballs. Another lesson I learned (It's lame applying this from paintabll, I know), was field vision. I played with a friend of mine who was in the army several times, and he would even walk around alone (without the benefit of leapfrogging cover), and just straight up stalk people and wipe out whole teams. just because he had this weird sixth sense about where everyone was and he could stop, look and pick out camoflauged targets, even the one's that made little movement. it was eerie. in any case, I don't envy the jobs of soldiers. you could be the baddest, most competent mutha on the block and still catch one and die.
 
© 2008 John Donovan
All rights reserved.